Tool 2LS 0.6.0 CBMC 5.8 CPAchecker 1.6.1-svn 26773 DepthK DepthK version 3.0 - Fri Jan 6 18:14:20 AMT 2017 ESBMC ESBMC version 4.6.0 64-bit x86_64 linux Map2Check Map2Check 7.1 : Wed Nov 22 22:30:11 -04 2017 symbiotic 5.0.0-KLEE:1faddfe0-dg:12c34aac-symbiotic:5e14b94d-minisat:3db58943-llvm-instrumentation:cd767593-stp:17249213 ULTIMATE Automizer 0.1.23-3204b741 ULTIMATE Kojak 0.1.23-3204b741 ULTIMATE Taipan 0.1.23-3204b741
Limits timelimit: 900 s, memlimit: 15000 MB, CPU core limit: 8
Host apollon*
OS Linux 4.4.0-101-generic
System CPU: Intel Xeon E3-1230 v5 @ 3.40 GHz, cores: 8, frequency: 3.8 GHz, Turbo Boost: disabled; RAM: 33553 MB
Date of execution 2017-12-01 10:20:37 CET 2017-12-01 11:16:27 CET 2017-12-01 10:49:29 CET 2017-12-01 13:07:37 CET 2017-12-02 06:23:16 CET 2017-12-02 18:23:42 CET 2017-12-02 00:52:46 CET 2017-12-03 04:09:48 CET 2017-12-03 11:17:40 CET 2017-12-03 08:43:49 CET
Run set 2ls.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] cbmc.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] cpa-seq.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] depthk.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] esbmc-incr.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] esbmc-kind.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] map2check.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] symbiotic.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] uautomizer.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] ukojak.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] utaipan.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other]
Options --graphml-witness witness.graphml --graphml-witness witness.graphml -svcomp18 -heap 10000M -benchmark -timelimit 900s -s incr -s kinduction --witness witness.graphml --full-output --full-output --full-output
../sv-benchmarks/c/ status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J)
signedintegeroverflow-regression/AdditionIntMax_false-no-overflow.c.i .13  24 .86 .25 34 2.5 3.4 300 29 4.1  410 30   .12  28 .72 .11  28 .83 .32  11 3.7  .17  11 1.8  4.1 240 32 4.3 240 36 4.1 240 34
signedintegeroverflow-regression/AdditionIntMin_false-no-overflow.c.i .14  24 .95 .26 34 2.5 3.5 280 32 3.8  420 33   .082 28 .93 .092 28 .97 .32  12 3.8  .17  11 1.5  4.8 260 40 4.4 260 38 4.7 270 41
signedintegeroverflow-regression/Division_false-no-overflow.c.i .10  24 1.0  .27 34 2.1 3.6 280 32 4.2  420 27   .082 28 .98 .079 28 1.1  .30  12 4.2  .16  11 1.7  4.1 240 38 4.4 250 35 4.1 240 34
signedintegeroverflow-regression/Multiplication_false-no-overflow.c.i .14  24 .85 .25 34 2.5 3.4 280 27 3.9  420 39   .097 28 .70 .11  28 .82 .31  11 2.7  .16  11 1.7  4.2 240 37 4.2 250 37 4.3 240 37
signedintegeroverflow-regression/NoConversion_false-no-overflow.c.i .10  24 .89 .25 34 2.4 3.4 280 34 4.2  420 29   .12  28 .81 .081 28 1.0  .30  11 3.5  .17  11 1.5  4.1 230 32 4.1 240 35 4.0 240 35
signedintegeroverflow-regression/PostfixDecrement_false-no-overflow.c.i .12  24 .93 .26 34 2.1 3.5 280 31 4.0  410 32   .092 28 1.1  .083 28 .90 .32  11 3.4  .14  11 1.9  4.7 270 44 4.5 270 35 4.4 270 39
signedintegeroverflow-regression/PostfixIncrement_false-no-overflow.c.i .10  24 1.3  .24 34 2.3 3.4 280 29 3.9  420 30   .11  28 .77 .11  28 .76 .32  12 3.2  .14  11 1.7  4.2 240 39 4.2 250 38 4.0 240 35
signedintegeroverflow-regression/PrefixDecrement_false-no-overflow.c.i .13  24 .81 .24 34 2.0 3.7 280 32 4.1  420 30   .11  28 .77 .10  28 .97 .29  11 4.2  .15  11 1.7  4.5 270 38 4.4 250 34 4.4 260 34
signedintegeroverflow-regression/PrefixIncrement_false-no-overflow.c.i .13  24 .92 .26 34 2.2 3.4 270 31 4.0  420 31   .083 28 .88 .12  28 .58 .30  12 4.0  .14  11 1.8  4.1 250 36 4.2 240 37 4.1 240 33
signedintegeroverflow-regression/UnaryMinus_false-no-overflow.c.i .14  24 .77 .27 34 2.2 3.5 280 31 4.0  420 32   .080 28 1.0  .082 28 .83 .32  11 3.5  .17  11 1.7  4.1 240 35 4.6 240 42 4.1 250 38
signedintegeroverflow-regression/ConversionToSignedInt_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c.i .12  24 .80 .44 34 5.1 3.0 270 24 1.3  48 15   .072 26 .92 .081 26 .77 .32  11 3.6  .15  11 1.4  4.0 240 34 4.0 240 35 4.3 240 33
signedintegeroverflow-regression/IntegerPromotion_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c.i .13  24 .80 .47 34 4.4 3.1 270 30 1.6  49 20   .088 27 .89 .089 27 .77 .30  11 4.5  .16  11 1.4  4.6 290 38 4.4 260 36 4.7 280 42
signedintegeroverflow-regression/Multiplication_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c.i .11  24 .79 .44 34 4.1 3.1 280 28 1.7  48 21   .072 26 .96 .080 27 .76 .32  11 3.7  .15  11 1.3  4.0 230 34 3.9 240 31 4.3 250 34
signedintegeroverflow-regression/NoNegativeIntegerConstant_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c.i .11  24 .91 .47 34 4.3 3.0 280 24 480    420 5400   .079 26 .90 .088 26 .72 .29  11 3.9  .15  11 1.6  4.1 240 35 4.0 230 31 4.2 240 32
signedintegeroverflow-regression/UsualArithmeticConversions_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c.i .11  24 .78 .46 34 4.3 2.9 270 29 480    110 6200   .073 26 1.0  .075 26 .84 .29  12 4.5  .15  11 1.5  4.4 240 34 4.0 240 36 4.1 240 31
termination-crafted/2Nested_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .77 .24 33 2.0 2.6 270 26 .53 75 6.6 .15  28 2.1  .21  28 1.6  .69  12 8.0  .19  12 1.9  6.1 340 49 4.1 250 35 4.2 240 36
termination-crafted/4NestedWith3Variables_false-no-overflow.c .15  24 .98 .28 36 2.6 2.6 270 24 .60 75 6.7 .36  28 2.9  .41  28 4.0  1.1   13 13    .18  12 1.6  4.1 250 38 4.3 250 37 4.3 250 37
termination-crafted/Ackermann_false-no-overflow.c .098 22 .71 .25 33 2.5 900   3800 11000 .61 49 7.3 .16  28 1.6  .20  28 1.7  .50  12 5.7  .17  12 1.9  4.0 240 38 4.3 250 38 4.2 250 35
termination-crafted/Bangalore_false-no-overflow.c .14  22 .92 .24 33 2.8 2.6 270 26 .55 75 6.7 .15  28 1.9  .19  28 2.4  .60  13 7.4  .18  12 1.8  4.0 240 37 4.2 240 38 4.3 250 38
termination-crafted/Bangalore_v3_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .95 .24 33 2.3 2.6 270 24 .54 75 6.0 .19  28 1.8  .17  28 2.2  .75  13 9.3  .18  12 2.7  4.2 240 36 4.0 240 35 4.1 240 32
termination-crafted/Benghazi_nondet_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .87 .27 33 2.2 2.7 280 27 .56 75 6.9 .23  28 2.0  .24  28 3.2  .68  12 9.7  .16  12 1.9  4.0 230 36 4.2 250 37 4.6 250 34
termination-crafted/Binary_Search_false-no-overflow.c .10  22 .65 .28 34 2.6 2.9 290 25 .40 48 5.0 .22  28 2.1  .35  28 3.3  .58  12 6.8  .17  12 2.1  4.2 250 34 4.3 260 38 4.1 240 34
termination-crafted/Cairo_nondet_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .98 .26 33 2.1 2.7 270 22 .85 75 12   .17  28 1.8  .18  28 1.5  .67  12 8.9  .17  12 2.1  4.4 280 36 5.3 290 40 4.6 290 35
termination-crafted/Cairo_step2_false-no-overflow.c 900     1300 11000    870    5100 5000   900   2600 13000 77    75 1000   900     390 10000    900     390 11000    900     1100 11000    900     170 13000    900   4400 14000 900   5200 12000 900   2400 13000
termination-crafted/Collatz_unknown-termination_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .98 .26 33 2.3 2.8 280 28 21    75 260   .14  28 1.4  .24  28 2.3  .43  12 5.1  .17  12 2.0  5.0 290 40 4.2 250 36 5.2 290 41
termination-crafted/Copenhagen_disj_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .75 .27 33 2.0 2.7 270 24 .40 75 4.7 .22  28 1.9  .24  28 1.9  .49  12 5.7  .18  12 1.6  4.4 270 36 4.3 250 37 4.5 280 35
termination-crafted/Gothenburg_false-no-overflow.c .13  25 1.2  .26 35 2.0 2.7 270 24 .61 75 7.4 .32  28 2.6  .42  28 3.4  3.6   14 43    .19  12 1.7  4.2 250 37 4.2 250 33 4.2 250 36
termination-crafted/Gothenburg_v2_false-no-overflow.c .13  25 .97 .29 33 2.4 2.7 270 22 .57 75 7.7 .32  28 3.1  .37  28 4.0  .41  12 4.5  .18  12 1.6  4.3 250 38 4.4 250 33 4.1 250 34
termination-crafted/Hanoi_2vars_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 1.0  .26 33 2.0 2.6 270 24 .53 75 6.4 .18  28 1.7  .20  28 1.8  26     15000 390    .16  12 1.9  4.0 240 35 4.1 250 35 4.0 240 35
termination-crafted/Hanoi_3vars_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .80 .23 33 2.2 2.7 270 22 .54 75 6.9 .23  28 2.1  .41  28 3.9  .68  13 8.4  .18  12 1.8  4.2 240 36 4.3 250 38 4.2 250 33
termination-crafted/Hanoi_plus_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .86 .25 33 2.3 2.7 270 25 .55 75 6.0 .32  28 2.4  .24  28 3.3  .99  13 12    .18  12 1.7  4.3 230 39 4.3 250 41 4.3 240 32
termination-crafted/Lobnya-Boolean-Reordered_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .86 .25 33 2.1 2.5 270 24 .37 75 4.3 .17  28 1.7  .15  28 1.9  .42  12 5.6  .18  12 1.7  4.4 270 35 6.9 370 51 4.7 280 38
termination-crafted/Mysore_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .81 .24 33 2.3 2.7 270 23 .56 75 6.6 .24  28 1.6  .23  28 2.4  .83  12 10    .16  12 2.1  6.3 340 47 4.2 250 39 4.0 240 37
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_1a_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .68 .25 33 2.6 2.7 270 26 .57 49 6.5 .13  28 1.3  .18  28 1.9  .35  12 4.3  .16  12 1.8  4.2 250 35 4.4 250 39 4.2 250 33
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_2a_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .75 .24 33 2.1 2.7 270 26 .52 48 5.6 .12  28 1.5  .14  28 1.2  .38  11 3.4  .15  12 2.1  4.5 280 44 4.3 250 36 4.7 280 38
termination-crafted/NonTermination1_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .87 .27 33 2.1 2.7 280 24 .55 75 6.2 .13  28 1.4  .15  28 1.1  .39  12 4.8  .18  12 1.8  3.9 240 34 4.2 240 38 4.1 250 37
termination-crafted/NonTermination2_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .86 .24 33 2.2 3.0 280 27 .38 75 4.3 .13  28 1.1  .26  28 1.7  .48  12 5.3  .16  12 1.9  4.1 240 37 4.1 250 38 6.8 350 44
termination-crafted/NonTermination4_false-no-overflow.c .53  41 5.7  1.8  35 20   190   1300 1500 12    75 140   .12  28 1.2  .12  28 1.2  .30  11 3.8  .16  11 2.0  23   780 200 350   4900 4900 250   2200 2700
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple2_false-no-overflow.c .14  22 .77 .23 33 2.5 2.8 270 23 .55 75 5.6 .13  28 1.3  .16  28 1.2  .41  12 5.5  .15  11 1.7  4.0 230 36 4.3 240 34 4.2 240 33
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple3_false-no-overflow.c .099 23 1.0  .27 33 2.0 2.7 270 21 .55 75 6.4 .16  28 1.8  .22  28 2.1  .58  13 8.0  .15  12 1.7  4.2 240 38 4.0 240 35 4.0 240 37
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple4_false-no-overflow.c 900     1200 13000    880    5100 4300   900   2200 12000 76    75 950   900     400 12000    900     390 12000    900     83 4200    .099 11 1.2  900   3900 15000 900   5200 13000 900   2500 15000
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple5_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .82 .25 33 2.1 2.7 270 23 .55 75 6.3 .13  28 1.1  .12  28 1.5  .42  12 4.8  .17  11 1.7  4.5 280 37 4.3 250 37 4.6 290 37
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple6_false-no-overflow.c .14  22 .91 .23 33 1.9 2.6 270 23 .54 75 6.5 .13  28 1.6  .20  28 1.6  26     15000 370    .18  12 1.9  4.0 240 36 4.1 240 36 4.1 230 36
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple8_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 1.1  .28 33 2.0 2.7 280 26 .57 75 7.2 .15  28 1.2  .16  28 1.7  .44  12 5.3  .18  11 1.7  6.1 330 45 4.1 250 39 4.0 250 39
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple9_false-no-overflow.c .14  22 .80 .23 33 2.4 2.7 280 26 .53 75 7.7 .12  28 1.3  .13  28 1.3  26     15000 360    .18  12 1.8  4.3 240 36 4.1 240 36 4.2 250 35
termination-crafted/Pure2Phase_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .87 .26 33 2.0 2.6 270 23 .55 75 6.0 .19  28 1.9  .27  28 2.1  .43  12 5.5  .19  12 1.4  4.7 280 36 4.5 250 39 4.8 280 37
termination-crafted/Pure3Phase_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .85 .25 35 2.4 2.7 270 25 .58 75 6.6 .26  28 2.2  .27  28 2.8  1.6   13 22    .16  12 2.6  4.2 240 33 4.5 250 34 4.2 250 33
termination-crafted/RecursiveMultiplication_false-no-overflow.c .10  22 .65 .25 33 2.2 3.5 300 30 .57 49 7.7 .16  28 1.7  .19  28 1.9  .80  12 12    .17  12 1.9  4.4 250 34 4.2 250 38 4.3 250 38
termination-crafted/RecursiveNonterminating_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .71 .27 33 2.2 2.6 270 21 .56 49 7.0 .13  28 1.6  .11  28 1.5  .33  11 3.6  .16  14 1.8  4.3 240 34 4.0 250 32 4.0 250 37
termination-crafted/Rotation180_false-no-overflow.c .11  24 .68 .26 33 2.1 2.6 260 23 .36 75 4.1 .12  28 1.2  .21  28 2.2  890     11 14000    .18  12 1.7  4.1 240 34 4.2 250 36 4.0 240 33
termination-crafted/Singapore_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .81 .25 33 2.1 2.6 270 22 .56 75 6.7 .17  28 2.5  .21  28 1.9  .60  13 7.8  .19  12 1.8  4.0 240 36 4.3 250 34 4.4 240 36
termination-crafted/Singapore_plus_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 1.0  .28 35 2.1 2.8 270 23 .56 75 6.5 .20  28 2.0  .29  28 2.9  .64  12 7.6  .19  12 1.8  4.1 240 34 4.4 250 38 4.2 240 32
termination-crafted/Singapore_v1_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 1.0  .27 33 2.3 2.5 260 23 .54 75 8.1 .19  28 2.0  .20  28 1.9  .68  12 8.4  .17  12 2.1  4.2 240 35 4.3 250 36 4.2 240 38
termination-crafted/Singapore_v2_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .83 .27 33 2.2 2.6 270 26 .55 75 7.0 .17  28 1.9  .21  28 1.9  .69  12 8.1  .16  12 1.9  4.1 240 36 4.2 250 34 4.3 250 35
termination-crafted/Stockholm_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .89 .24 33 2.0 2.7 270 22 .57 75 7.5 .29  28 2.2  .32  28 2.5  1.8   13 22    .18  12 1.7  4.3 240 39 4.2 250 41 4.4 250 35
termination-crafted/Thun_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .76 .27 33 2.0 2.7 270 23 .54 75 6.2 .18  28 1.6  .27  28 2.4  1.1   13 16    .18  12 1.7  4.0 240 33 4.3 250 33 4.0 250 33
termination-crafted/Toulouse-BranchesToLoop_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 1.1  .27 33 2.1 2.7 270 22 .57 75 6.9 .17  28 1.5  .28  28 1.8  .95  12 13    .16  12 1.8  4.9 280 41 4.5 250 41 4.8 290 38
termination-crafted/Toulouse-MultiBranchesToLoop_false-no-overflow.c .12  24 1.1  .27 33 2.5 3.1 280 28 .62 77 7.9 .55  28 4.4  .57  28 5.7  1.4   12 19    .20  12 1.9  13   660 120 12   540 120 13   610 100
termination-crafted/aaron2_false-no-overflow.c .14  25 .85 .24 35 2.5 2.7 280 28 .41 75 4.6 .25  28 2.3  .34  28 3.3  .93  13 12    .16  12 2.3  4.7 280 43 4.1 250 36 4.6 280 38
termination-crafted/aaron3_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .76 .26 33 2.2 2.7 270 23 .39 75 4.6 .26  28 2.5  .33  28 2.9  .79  13 10    .19  12 2.4  6.0 320 40 4.2 250 39 4.3 250 40
termination-crafted/easy2_false-no-overflow.c 900     1700 12000    870    2200 3100   900   13000 10000 160    390 2300   900     890 11000    900     880 11000    900     300 11000    900     210 13000    900   5300 14000 900   7000 13000 900   5300 13000
termination-crafted/4BitCounterPointer_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .19  24 1.4  2.2  34 28   2.6 270 24 1.2  76 14   .087 26 .89 .074 26 .79 .34  11 3.5  .13  11 1.5  7.3 360 56 4.6 260 42 4.5 260 36
termination-crafted/Arrays01-EquivalentConstantIndices_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 5.9   200 66    870    3000 3200   2.9 270 25 60    100 790   900     1600 11000    .12  26 .57 890     100 12000    900     250 11000    30   940 320 900   5200 14000 900   1500 11000
termination-crafted/Arrays02-EquivalentConstantIndices_true-no-overflow_false-termination.c 3.0   100 31    870    3900 4200   2.7 270 24 1.3  75 14   900     1500 14000    .072 26 .78 900     32 11000    900     70 11000    4.6 280 36 4.5 260 42 4.8 280 40
termination-crafted/Arrays03-ValueRestictsIndex_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 3.3   170 37    870    3800 3000   900   6200 11000 1.4  100 18   900     1100 11000    .089 26 .78 3.0   140 33    900     180 12000    5.7 300 51 7.0 470 63 6.8 330 60
termination-crafted/Bangalore_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .10  22 .73 870    5300 4700   2.7 270 25 7.6  75 92   900     130 10000    .10  26 .85 900     60 10000    900     52 12000    5.2 300 44 7.0 460 58 5.5 290 49
termination-crafted/Bangalore_v2_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .087 23 .86 870    5500 5800   2.7 270 28 7.2  75 89   900     190 12000    .089 26 1.1  900     58 12000    900     55 14000    5.3 300 42 6.2 420 59 5.5 300 42
termination-crafted/Bangalore_v4_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .17  24 1.2  .45 33 3.8 2.6 270 25 1.5  75 15   .12  26 1.2  .096 26 .95 .49  12 5.2  .20  12 2.0  5.0 300 43 5.3 290 40 5.8 300 50
termination-crafted/Benghazi_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 900     310 8400    870    2200 3200   900   4900 11000 380    560 4700   900     1300 9700    900     1300 11000    900     930 12000    900     100 13000    17   720 150 900   5700 12000 24   800 220
termination-crafted/Cairo_step2_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .12  22 .68 870    8400 3400   2.6 270 21 1.2  75 18   .056 15 .25 .033 15 .31 900     1200 11000    .080 11 .63 4.1 230 38 4.0 240 32 4.1 240 37
termination-crafted/Cairo_step2_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 900     1300 12000    870    4600 5900   900   2600 10000 68    75 850   900     440 11000    900     450 12000    900     1100 11000    900     270 13000    4.9 300 40 4.9 270 44 5.3 300 43
termination-crafted/Cairo_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 900     1400 13000    870    4500 4000   2.8 270 23 1.4  75 20   900     400 9700    900     400 11000    900     1200 12000    900     170 11000    4.6 290 46 5.1 270 41 5.1 280 43
termination-crafted/Copenhagen_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  23 .87 870    3200 4900   2.7 270 22 1.3  75 16   900     760 11000    .075 26 .77 900     1100 9900    900     230 13000    5.5 310 53 6.8 420 51 6.4 300 51
termination-crafted/Division_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  23 .83 870    3900 3500   2.9 290 23 1.5  75 17   900     630 13000    .082 26 .86 900     26 12000    900     15 14000    4.7 290 39 5.8 310 45 7.6 390 50
termination-crafted/LexIndexValue-Array_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 6.3   280 63    50    14000 600   2.7 270 25 38    100 500   750     15000 11000    .11  26 .96 900     1900 11000    300     2900 2500    900   4900 13000 900   5300 15000 900   1600 11000
termination-crafted/LexIndexValue-Pointer_true-no-overflow.c .16  24 1.7  58    14000 730   900   6300 9900 120    160 1500   900     5900 11000    900     5900 11000    900     1900 12000    900     3800 7900    900   2000 11000 900   6200 11000 900   1300 12000
termination-crafted/Madrid_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .13  22 .69 210    15000 2800   2.5 270 24 1.2  75 12   900     11000 9700    .082 26 .66 890     11 12000    .13  11 1.3  3.8 240 37 3.9 230 35 4.3 240 34
termination-crafted/McCarthy91_Iteration_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 900     1500 10000    870    1200 8200   900   600 12000 900    120 9700   900     150 12000    900     150 11000    900     110 13000    900     76 12000    900   5200 11000 900   5300 14000 900   3900 13000
termination-crafted/McCarthy91_Recursion_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .10  22 .64 870    2000 2900   2.9 280 27 510    15000 7100   900     6400 7300    900     9000 9500    900     140 11000    900     72 12000    6.3 310 53 6.6 400 52 6.4 310 51
termination-crafted/MenloPark_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 900     750 7700    870    3200 4100   2.9 270 25 1.4  75 16   900     1000 11000    900     1000 10000    900     940 12000    900     100 12000    9.8 540 79 18   670 170 7.2 320 55
termination-crafted/MutualRecursion_1a_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .12  22 .69 870    310 3700   3.9 290 33 450    15000 6300   900     12000 6500    720     15000 7600    900     600 12000    900     92 12000    8.5 450 66 900   1200 14000 16   640 140
termination-crafted/MutualRecursion_1b_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .12  22 .66 870    290 2400   4.0 290 40 440    15000 6000   900     12000 6200    670     15000 7800    900     260 11000    900     130 11000    19   790 170 900   1200 12000 44   1100 390
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_1b_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .12  22 .64 870    710 3800   900   1200 13000 440    15000 5900   900     4900 6300    900     4800 12000    900     460 12000    900     360 13000    12   560 93 900   1500 13000 23   670 180
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_1c_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  22 .67 870    480 3200   3.3 280 30 390    15000 4400   900     4900 6800    770     15000 6700    900     460 10000    900     290 14000    8.4 480 71 900   1600 14000 13   580 110
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_1d_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .10  22 .84 870    700 3600   900   1400 9800 440    15000 6000   900     4800 5200    680     15000 6600    900     490 13000    900     400 12000    12   530 99 900   1800 11000 15   610 110
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_2b_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .086 22 .64 870    810 6200   900   5100 9900 500    15000 5300   900     6100 6000    900     12000 7200    900     2400 9200    900     980 11000    11   550 83 900   2000 11000 9.5 520 76
termination-crafted/NestedRecursion_2c_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .097 22 .64 870    4100 5400   900   4300 11000 500    15000 7300   890     15000 7700    900     12000 10000    900     1600 10000    900     270 10000    14   610 120 900   5000 12000 14   610 120
termination-crafted/NonTermination3_true-no-overflow_false-termination.c .11  23 .80 870    2700 5600   2.6 270 22 1.2  75 13   900     2100 11000    .079 26 .74 .41  12 5.0  .13  11 1.6  4.1 240 33 4.0 240 40 3.9 230 31
termination-crafted/NonTerminationSimple7_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .12  22 .84 870    5300 4400   2.7 270 26 1.4  75 16   900     170 11000    .072 26 .89 890     11 12000    .16  11 1.6  5.3 300 45 6.4 380 52 5.8 300 46
termination-crafted/Nyala-2lex_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  25 .81 870    2200 6500   2.7 270 23 1.4  75 17   900     380 12000    .10  26 .62 900     650 13000    900     4000 10000    4.9 280 44 6.3 390 55 6.8 360 60
termination-crafted/Parallel_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  23 .83 870    2100 6800   2.6 270 24 1.3  75 17   900     400 9700    .076 26 .86 900     250 11000    900     250 12000    4.9 280 42 6.1 380 52 4.9 290 38
termination-crafted/Piecewise_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .14  23 .75 870    830 9100   2.7 270 26 1.2  75 16   900     220 12000    .12  26 1.1  900     140 11000    900     170 12000    5.0 290 41 6.0 340 50 4.9 300 44
termination-crafted/SyntaxSupportPointer01_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .15  23 1.7  870    4500 4000   2.6 270 26 72    75 1000   900     720 11000    900     720 11000    900     460 11000    900     250 12000    5.5 300 46 5.8 320 50 5.0 280 41
termination-crafted/TelAviv-Amir-Minimum_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  23 .72 870    1300 9500   2.7 260 23 1.3  75 15   900     410 14000    .12  26 .86 900     440 12000    900     330 11000    5.7 300 45 6.5 380 62 5.6 300 46
termination-crafted/Waldkirch_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .10  22 .74 870    5100 4100   2.6 270 23 1.4  75 14   900     740 11000    .11  26 .72 900     260 11000    900     210 13000    4.8 290 38 5.1 260 47 4.7 280 36
termination-crafted/WhileFalse_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .10  22 .84 .39 33 5.0 2.7 290 25 1.2  48 12   .069 26 .84 .093 26 .73 .29  11 3.5  .14  11 1.3  4.1 240 33 3.8 240 31 4.0 240 35
termination-crafted/WhileTrue_true-no-overflow_false-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .10  22 .72 .41 33 4.3 2.6 270 24 1.2  75 13   290     15000 4400    .10  26 .68 890     11 12000    .13  11 1.4  4.1 240 37 3.8 230 33 4.2 240 31
termination-crafted/easy1_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c .11  22 .92 4.2  61 55   2.7 270 22 1.4  75 17   .61  26 8.6  .11  26 .66 .38  11 4.3  .15  11 1.5  4.8 290 37 5.7 310 45 4.8 290 39
termination-crafted/easy2_true-no-overflow_true-termination_true-valid-memsafety.c 900     1700 9900    870    2400 4200   900   13000 11000 120    240 1600   900     900 12000    900     890 10000    900     310 9900    900     180 12000    900   5300 13000 900   7100 11000 7.4 350 60
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-Fig2a_false-no-overflow.c .15  23 .84 .27 33 1.9 2.8 270 24 .58 100 6.9 .29  28 2.3  .41  29 4.6  .41  12 6.0  .19  12 1.9  4.7 300 43 4.7 260 36 4.7 290 40
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-Fig2b_false-no-overflow.c .13  26 1.1  .28 36 2.6 2.7 280 26 .60 130 6.5 .29  28 3.0  .56  30 6.8  .43  12 6.0  .19  12 1.9  5.1 280 46 4.9 260 42 5.1 290 38
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-aaron2_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .93 .25 33 2.1 2.6 270 24 .40 75 4.7 .24  28 2.8  .26  28 3.2  .92  13 13    .20  12 1.8  4.6 280 38 4.3 250 42 4.8 280 40
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-aaron3_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .88 .24 33 2.5 2.8 270 24 .39 75 4.4 .27  28 2.9  .35  28 2.8  .82  13 10    .22  12 2.4  4.4 240 36 4.3 250 37 4.4 250 36
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-complex_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .98 .29 33 2.6 2.6 270 21 .63 100 6.9 .23  28 1.8  .38  28 3.7  .68  13 7.9  .21  12 2.0  5.9 300 49 6.2 380 59 6.3 290 47
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-counterex1a_false-no-overflow.c .14  25 .96 .28 33 2.3 2.8 270 26 .38 75 4.8 .25  28 2.2  .38  28 2.9  .72  12 7.8  .17  12 2.1  4.0 240 37 4.6 250 44 4.3 250 35
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-counterex1b_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 1.1  .26 33 2.7 2.8 270 26 .58 130 6.7 .20  28 1.8  .36  28 3.8  1.2   13 16    .25  12 2.7  7.1 370 56 5.9 340 51 5.2 290 42
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-easy2_false-no-overflow.c 900     1700 12000    870    2400 3400   900   13000 11000 160    390 2100   900     890 12000    900     890 11000    900     270 11000    900     200 10000    900   5300 15000 900   7000 10000 900   5300 12000
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-exmini_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .90 .26 33 1.5 2.6 270 23 .39 75 4.5 .27  28 2.4  .36  28 3.8  .53  13 6.5  .16  12 1.9  5.0 290 42 5.9 320 52 4.7 280 40
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-ndecr_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .87 .25 33 1.9 2.6 270 24 .54 75 6.0 .13  28 1.4  .14  28 1.1  .30  11 3.6  .19  12 1.7  4.5 280 38 4.5 250 37 4.7 290 36
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-nestedLoop_false-no-overflow.c 900     3000 5800    870    1500 5000   900   6200 10000 900    710 6100   900     1100 11000    900     1000 9700    890     620 12000    900     1900 9800    900   5000 13000 900   6000 12000 900   3000 15000
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-random1d_false-no-overflow.c 900     1000 9500    870    590 9400   910   620 13000 900    140 12000   900     120 12000    900     120 9600    900     350 14000    900     4000 8700    900   8500 9900 900   6700 12000 900   3800 12000
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-rsd_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .84 .25 33 2.0 2.9 280 27 .56 75 6.5 .15  28 1.3  .13  28 1.5  .40  12 5.0  .18  12 1.9  4.1 250 35 4.3 250 35 4.4 250 34
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-speedFails4_false-no-overflow.c .14  25 .85 .25 33 2.2 2.7 280 24 .55 75 6.6 .22  28 2.5  .26  28 2.3  31     15000 470    .19  12 1.8  4.4 240 39 4.1 250 36 4.2 250 32
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-terminate_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .80 .27 33 2.0 2.7 270 23 .39 75 4.8 .27  28 2.4  .35  28 3.7  .50  13 6.5  .19  12 2.0  4.9 290 41 5.5 310 48 4.9 280 42
termination-crafted-lit/Ben-Amram-LMCS2010-Ex2.3_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .83 .25 33 2.3 2.8 270 23 .38 75 4.7 .28  28 2.2  .45  28 3.7  .61  12 8.0  .19  12 1.9  4.9 300 39 4.7 270 39 4.7 290 37
termination-crafted-lit/BradleyMannaSipma-ICALP2005-Fig1_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .86 .25 33 2.6 2.7 270 25 .61 76 7.1 .24  28 2.2  .26  28 2.5  25     15000 310    .20  12 1.9  4.8 280 37 4.6 250 36 4.7 290 40
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-aaron12_false-no-overflow.c .15  29 1.5  .35 38 2.6 2.7 270 23 480    130 6900   .42  29 4.2  .69  32 6.7  1.9   20 22    .17  12 2.3  4.4 250 37 4.3 250 36 4.3 250 39
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-aaron1_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .82 .28 35 2.4 2.8 270 22 .40 75 4.7 .27  28 2.6  .31  28 2.9  .68  12 8.2  .21  12 2.1  4.5 250 36 4.6 250 35 4.4 250 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-aaron2_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 1.0  .27 33 2.2 2.7 270 23 .41 75 4.5 .25  28 2.7  .29  28 3.4  .98  13 11    .20  12 1.8  4.5 280 38 4.3 240 37 4.5 290 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-aaron3_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .82 .25 33 2.2 2.6 270 23 .39 75 4.8 .30  28 2.6  .33  28 2.9  .81  13 9.6  .20  12 2.3  4.2 240 40 4.2 260 36 4.3 250 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-aaron4_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .94 .28 33 2.2 2.7 270 25 .44 76 4.8 .37  28 4.0  .47  29 4.2  .82  12 11    .21  12 2.0  4.2 240 36 4.3 260 34 4.5 260 38
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-aaron6_false-no-overflow.c .13  24 .81 .27 33 2.3 2.6 270 26 .42 76 4.6 .31  28 3.4  .42  28 4.3  26     15000 360    .20  12 1.9  4.3 250 39 4.4 260 42 4.2 250 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex1.01_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .95 .25 33 1.9 2.7 270 24 .55 75 6.4 .12  28 1.2  .14  28 1.4  .48  12 6.3  .17  12 1.7  4.5 280 41 4.3 250 36 4.5 280 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex1.02_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .86 .24 33 2.7 2.7 270 23 .37 75 5.1 .11  28 1.3  .13  28 1.2  1.1   12 16    .17  12 2.2  4.3 240 35 4.3 240 34 4.3 240 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex1.03_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 1.1  .23 33 2.8 2.6 280 22 .39 75 4.4 .12  28 1.5  .12  28 1.3  .37  11 4.8  .17  12 2.0  4.4 280 37 4.4 250 35 4.4 290 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex1.04_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 .75 .24 33 1.8 2.7 290 28 .39 75 4.3 .11  28 1.5  .16  28 1.1  .38  12 4.5  .17  12 1.9  4.2 240 32 4.2 250 39 4.1 240 36
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex1.05_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .88 .26 33 2.1 2.8 280 26 .38 75 5.0 .13  28 1.2  .14  28 1.2  .36  12 4.4  .20  12 2.0  4.1 230 34 4.2 250 35 4.1 240 36
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.01_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .81 .27 33 1.9 2.6 270 24 .54 75 7.4 .18  28 1.5  .19  28 1.9  .54  13 7.6  .17  12 1.8  3.9 230 31 4.2 250 34 4.3 240 39
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.02_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .83 .24 33 2.3 2.6 270 23 .54 75 6.8 .17  28 1.7  .29  28 3.1  .58  12 7.9  .17  12 2.0  4.5 280 39 4.3 250 40 4.6 280 38
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.03_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .82 .26 33 2.2 2.6 280 23 .56 75 6.6 .17  28 1.8  .30  28 2.8  .52  12 7.0  .17  12 2.1  4.2 240 39 4.3 250 37 4.1 240 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.04_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 1.1  .25 33 2.2 2.6 270 23 .56 75 6.3 .17  28 2.1  .21  28 1.9  .93  13 13    .17  12 1.6  4.2 240 32 4.2 250 41 4.2 240 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.05_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .84 .26 33 2.0 2.6 270 22 .56 75 7.4 .16  28 1.6  .22  28 2.3  27     15000 360    .18  12 1.9  4.1 250 41 4.3 240 35 4.2 240 33
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.06_false-no-overflow.c .15  24 1.1  .27 34 2.2 2.6 270 26 .40 75 4.5 .20  28 2.1  .24  28 2.5  1.1   12 14    .16  12 1.7  4.3 240 35 4.1 250 35 4.1 240 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.07_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .98 .27 33 2.2 2.8 290 29 .37 75 4.7 .18  28 1.5  .27  28 2.6  .58  12 7.8  .16  12 2.1  4.0 240 36 4.0 250 34 4.3 240 36
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.08_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .85 .26 33 2.2 2.7 270 22 .55 75 6.1 .20  28 1.5  .21  28 2.2  .72  12 9.7  .19  12 1.8  4.2 240 34 4.2 250 34 4.3 240 38
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.09_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .88 .26 33 2.0 2.6 260 22 .39 75 5.7 .21  28 2.1  .24  28 3.1  1.0   13 12    .17  12 1.9  4.9 290 43 5.2 290 42 5.3 290 43
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.10_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 .87 .25 33 2.4 2.7 270 23 .39 75 4.2 .18  28 1.5  .25  28 2.1  .49  12 6.1  .16  12 1.9  4.7 300 39 5.7 330 45 4.9 290 38
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.11_false-no-overflow.c .15  24 .77 .27 34 2.9 2.7 280 21 .40 75 4.4 .29  28 3.2  .37  29 4.5  .87  12 10    .19  12 1.6  6.2 330 45 4.3 250 36 4.1 240 31
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.12_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .83 .25 33 2.0 2.6 270 25 .55 75 6.3 .26  28 2.4  .31  28 2.7  1.3   13 19    .16  12 2.2  4.0 250 34 4.3 250 37 4.1 240 35
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.13_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .89 .28 33 2.0 2.6 270 22 .39 75 4.9 .19  28 2.7  .25  28 2.5  .73  12 9.6  .16  12 1.9  4.1 240 34 4.4 250 39 4.4 250 31
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.14_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .88 .26 33 2.0 2.6 270 22 .40 75 4.3 .19  28 2.5  .25  28 2.0  .58  12 6.3  .16  12 1.8  4.2 240 38 4.2 250 38 4.4 250 33
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.15_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .89 .26 33 1.8 2.8 270 22 .54 75 5.5 .17  28 1.8  .17  28 1.9  .54  12 6.4  .18  12 1.8  4.2 240 37 4.2 240 35 4.0 240 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.16_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .81 .27 33 2.1 2.6 260 23 .38 75 4.0 .16  28 1.5  .23  28 1.7  .40  12 5.3  .18  12 2.0  4.4 270 36 4.4 250 37 4.6 280 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.17_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .84 .24 33 2.5 2.6 260 25 .36 75 4.7 .18  28 1.6  .16  28 2.1  .44  11 6.0  .15  12 1.7  4.1 230 33 4.3 250 39 4.3 240 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.18_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .97 .25 33 2.8 2.8 270 24 .54 75 6.8 .18  28 1.9  .27  28 2.6  .69  12 9.4  .16  12 1.7  4.0 240 33 4.2 240 33 6.3 340 55
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.19_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .84 .23 33 2.9 2.6 260 22 .36 75 4.3 .18  28 1.7  .22  28 3.0  .86  12 9.9  .17  12 2.1  4.2 240 31 4.4 250 39 4.2 250 38
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.21_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 1.0  .28 33 2.1 2.8 270 23 .56 75 7.3 .17  28 1.7  .22  28 1.7  .51  12 6.9  .16  12 1.9  4.1 250 33 4.2 250 35 4.3 240 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.22_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .92 .24 33 2.7 2.6 270 23 .37 75 4.7 .17  28 1.9  .20  28 1.6  .44  12 6.1  .17  12 2.1  4.0 250 37 4.2 250 35 4.0 240 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.02_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .73 .23 33 2.3 2.7 270 23 .55 75 6.8 .25  28 2.1  .34  28 3.2  1.1   13 13    .16  12 2.1  4.4 250 33 4.3 250 38 4.2 250 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.03_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .80 .26 33 1.9 2.6 270 26 .55 75 5.7 .25  28 1.6  .37  28 4.9  .70  15 8.5  .18  12 1.7  6.5 340 48 4.1 250 40 6.1 340 45
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.04_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .99 .25 33 2.1 2.7 270 24 .37 75 4.3 .26  28 2.1  .35  28 3.0  .96  13 13    .17  12 1.8  4.3 250 37 4.7 260 33 4.1 240 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.05_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .89 .27 33 2.1 2.6 270 22 .38 75 5.2 .24  28 1.9  .27  28 2.4  .81  13 9.6  .17  12 2.3  4.2 240 34 4.2 250 39 3.9 230 31
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.06_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 1.1  .27 33 2.4 2.7 270 25 .54 75 7.0 .23  28 1.9  .22  28 2.1  .68  12 9.5  .16  12 1.9  4.6 280 35 4.5 260 35 4.8 280 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.07_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 1.1  .25 33 2.3 2.7 270 25 .56 75 7.5 .20  28 2.2  .23  28 2.2  1.7   13 23    .16  12 2.0  4.3 240 38 4.5 250 35 4.1 250 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.08_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .84 .24 33 2.2 2.7 260 23 .39 75 4.6 .23  28 2.0  .29  28 2.6  .85  14 10    .20  12 1.8  4.1 240 34 4.2 250 36 4.1 240 34
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.09_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .82 .24 35 2.3 3.2 310 29 .39 75 4.6 .20  28 1.4  .25  28 2.0  .78  12 8.4  .17  12 1.9  4.2 240 38 4.4 250 36 4.1 250 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.10_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .91 .25 33 1.9 2.7 270 25 .37 75 5.3 .22  28 2.2  .26  28 2.4  1.6   14 19    .21  12 2.0  4.2 250 37 4.2 250 35 4.3 250 35
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex4.01_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 1.1  .25 33 2.1 2.7 270 26 .38 75 3.9 .31  28 2.8  .32  28 3.1  1.1   13 13    .18  12 2.0  4.2 250 36 4.2 250 35 4.2 250 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Fig1_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .84 .25 33 2.1 2.8 270 22 .55 75 6.6 .23  28 2.1  .23  28 2.5  .49  13 5.8  .16  12 2.2  4.3 250 32 4.2 260 35 4.4 250 36
termination-crafted-lit/ColonSipma-TACAS2001-Fig1_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .80 .28 33 2.2 2.7 260 25 .39 75 4.8 .28  28 2.2  .41  28 3.3  .48  13 5.6  .19  12 1.8  4.9 290 39 5.6 300 48 4.7 290 40
termination-crafted-lit/GulavaniGulwani-CAV2008-Fig1a_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .80 .27 33 2.1 2.8 270 21 .56 75 6.8 .28  28 2.7  .30  28 3.1  .46  12 4.9  .18  12 1.8  4.1 240 33 4.2 250 34 4.2 250 37
termination-crafted-lit/GulavaniGulwani-CAV2008-Fig1b_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .99 .24 33 2.1 2.8 270 26 .56 100 6.6 .28  28 2.3  .49  28 4.5  .49  12 7.0  .16  12 2.1  4.2 240 37 4.2 250 33 4.3 250 34
termination-crafted-lit/GulavaniGulwani-CAV2008-Fig1c_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 1.0  .24 33 2.1 2.6 270 23 .55 75 6.6 .24  28 2.0  .22  28 2.6  26     15000 330    .18  12 1.8  4.1 240 38 4.3 250 35 4.2 240 40
termination-crafted-lit/GulwaniJainKoskinen-PLDI2009-Fig1_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .95 .28 33 2.1 2.7 280 24 .57 75 7.6 .21  28 1.9  .25  28 2.2  .57  12 7.9  .18  12 2.4  4.8 280 42 4.9 270 42 5.0 290 43
termination-crafted-lit/HarrisLalNoriRajamani-SAS2010-Fig2_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 1.2  .28 33 2.0 3.2 290 26 .65 79 8.1 .19  28 1.5  .16  28 1.7  3.4   15 46    .18  12 2.0  6.1 300 56 9.9 480 81 5.8 290 48
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig2_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .82 .29 33 2.0 2.7 270 26 .55 75 7.2 .20  28 1.9  .25  28 2.5  .46  12 5.2  .18  12 2.0  4.2 240 32 4.2 250 40 4.2 250 36
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig7_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .90 .24 33 2.6 2.8 270 24 .58 75 6.4 .18  28 1.5  .18  28 1.8  .052 11 .34 2.4   4300 25    4.9 290 43 4.9 260 38 4.7 280 38
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig8_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .96 .24 33 2.4 2.7 280 26 .56 75 6.4 .19  28 1.6  .18  28 2.1  .52  12 6.5  .18  12 1.6  4.1 240 32 4.3 250 36 4.4 250 36
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig9_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 1.0  .27 33 2.0 2.8 280 24 .57 75 6.8 .22  28 1.9  .25  28 2.3  .54  12 7.7  .16  12 1.7  4.1 240 37 4.3 240 38 4.3 240 34
termination-crafted-lit/LeeJonesBen-Amram-POPL2001-Ex1_false-no-overflow.c .098 22 .66 .26 33 2.3 3.0 280 26 .56 49 6.5 .14  28 1.3  .12  28 1.7  .41  12 5.9  .16  12 2.1  5.7 310 53 5.7 320 46 5.3 290 46
termination-crafted-lit/LeeJonesBen-Amram-POPL2001-Ex2_false-no-overflow.c .10  22 .62 .24 33 2.6 3.2 280 27 .56 49 7.7 .18  28 1.6  .19  28 2.2  .62  12 6.6  .18  12 2.0  5.1 290 42 5.5 320 43 5.2 290 41
termination-crafted-lit/LeeJonesBen-Amram-POPL2001-Ex3_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .86 .29 33 2.4 900   2500 8200 .57 49 6.3 .18  28 1.6  .20  28 1.5  .47  12 5.5  .18  12 2.0  4.3 240 34 4.3 250 39 4.3 240 32
termination-crafted-lit/LeeJonesBen-Amram-POPL2001-Ex6_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .59 .28 33 2.1 3.1 310 28 .56 51 7.4 .17  28 1.6  .21  28 1.8  .48  12 6.4  .16  12 1.6  4.0 240 35 4.4 250 38 4.4 240 37
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-TACAS2014-Ex7_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .94 .24 33 2.3 2.5 260 23 .55 75 6.1 .20  28 1.5  .19  28 2.4  .53  12 6.1  .18  12 1.8  4.2 240 37 4.2 250 33 4.3 250 32
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-TACAS2014-Ex8_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .91 .23 33 2.5 2.6 270 26 .56 75 5.9 .17  28 1.8  .20  28 1.9  .44  12 4.8  .16  12 1.8  4.5 280 39 4.5 250 36 4.6 280 40
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-TACAS2014-Fig1_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .72 .24 33 2.6 2.8 270 26 .55 75 7.0 .17  28 1.7  .23  28 3.1  .56  13 6.4  .18  12 1.7  4.3 240 33 4.1 250 32 4.1 240 32
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-WST2014-Ex5_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .94 .25 33 2.1 2.6 270 22 .55 75 6.4 .15  28 1.9  .26  28 2.9  26     15000 350    .16  12 1.9  4.0 240 34 4.0 250 31 3.9 240 30
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-WST2014-Ex6_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 1.3  .27 33 2.1 2.9 290 24 .36 75 4.5 .19  28 1.7  .21  28 1.8  .54  12 7.3  .18  12 2.0  4.2 240 35 6.1 340 46 4.2 240 35
termination-crafted-lit/Masse-VMCAI2014-Ex6_false-no-overflow.c .13  22 .74 .27 33 2.0 2.6 270 26 .54 75 7.2 .19  28 1.5  .22  28 1.7  .58  12 7.3  .19  12 1.7  4.0 240 32 4.1 250 38 4.2 240 34
termination-crafted-lit/Masse-VMCAI2014-Fig1a_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .82 .25 35 2.0 2.7 270 26 .53 75 6.5 .19  28 1.8  .21  28 1.7  .55  12 7.2  .16  12 2.0  4.0 250 36 4.1 250 32 4.2 250 32
termination-crafted-lit/Masse-VMCAI2014-Fig1b_false-no-overflow.c .14  23 .88 .26 33 2.1 2.7 270 27 .55 75 8.4 .19  28 1.9  .25  28 2.2  .71  12 8.3  .16  12 1.8  4.2 250 36 4.2 250 38 4.4 250 37
termination-crafted-lit/NoriSharma-FSE2013-Fig7_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .81 .28 33 1.9 2.9 270 25 .56 76 6.5 .27  28 2.5  .43  28 3.6  .57  12 6.9  .19  12 1.9  4.2 250 37 4.3 250 37 4.1 250 35
termination-crafted-lit/NoriSharma-FSE2013-Fig8_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .90 .25 33 2.7 2.9 270 25 .56 75 7.7 .28  28 2.6  .24  28 2.5  .82  13 10    .18  12 1.9  4.8 290 37 5.4 270 43 4.9 280 36
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-LICS2004-Fig2-TACAS2011-Fig3_false-no-overflow.c .12  23 .90 .25 33 2.2 2.8 270 24 .40 75 4.3 .24  28 2.5  .30  28 2.9  .52  12 5.1  .19  12 2.1  5.1 290 40 6.2 350 51 5.3 300 41
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-LICS2004-Fig2_false-no-overflow.c .14  22 .76 .28 33 2.2 2.7 270 25 .37 75 4.7 .29  28 2.4  .34  28 3.0  .48  12 5.5  .21  12 2.0  5.3 280 45 6.1 340 52 5.2 280 40
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-TACAS2011-Fig3_false-no-overflow.c .12  24 1.1  .23 33 2.4 2.7 270 23 .40 75 4.6 .25  28 2.1  .34  28 2.9  .50  12 5.5  .20  12 2.0  5.2 300 48 6.1 340 44 4.8 290 39
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-VMCAI2004-Ex1_false-no-overflow.c .13  23 .90 .26 33 2.0 2.7 270 23 .41 75 4.7 .24  28 2.3  .32  29 3.0  .55  12 6.1  .19  12 1.9  4.3 250 39 4.3 250 37 6.5 340 56
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-VMCAI2004-Ex2_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 1.2  .25 33 2.6 2.7 280 24 .55 75 7.2 .15  28 1.3  .15  28 1.4  .48  14 5.7  .16  12 2.1  4.5 280 40 4.3 250 33 4.5 270 37
termination-crafted-lit/cstrncmp_false-no-overflow.c .16  23 1.4  .44 34 4.6 3.7 330 34 .68 76 8.3 .34  29 2.8  .37  29 4.5  .064 11 .48 .24  13 2.6  8.0 370 61 6.4 350 54 5.8 290 51
termination-crafted-lit/gcd1_false-no-overflow.c .15  23 .86 .25 35 2.3 2.6 270 20 .57 100 6.5 .29  28 2.2  .26  28 3.7  900     120 12000    .20  12 2.2  4.4 250 37 4.2 250 37 4.0 250 31
termination-crafted-lit/joey_false-no-overflow.c .091 22 .78 .30 34 3.1 2.7 270 22 630    15000 8800   .13  28 1.3  .14  28 1.3  .43  12 5.1  .19  12 1.8  5.0 290 48 5.3 300 48 5.3 300 44
termination-crafted-lit/min_rf_false-no-overflow.c .10  23 .90 .27 35 2.1 2.8 270 26 .42 75 4.8 .27  28 2.9  .29  28 3.5  1.1   13 16    .18  12 1.7  4.4 250 37 4.4 250 40 4.3 250 34
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     900 7600    870    590 8400   850   15000 12000 890    120 9800   900     620 9300    900     590 11000    900     650 11000    900     4000 9000    900   5100 15000 900   6300 12000 900   3800 12000
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-cousot9_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .87 870    1800 6000   2.7 270 23 1.4  75 15   900     600 9700    .12  26 .65 900     340 11000    900     360 13000    5.3 300 42 6.8 470 61 8.6 400 75
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-easy1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .13  23 .81 4.3  61 44   2.7 260 23 1.4  75 18   .62  26 7.3  .074 26 .91 .39  11 4.3  .15  11 1.4  4.6 280 37 5.6 310 45 5.0 290 40
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-easy2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     1700 9800    870    2300 3900   900   13000 11000 120    240 1700   900     900 12000    900     900 11000    900     300 10000    900     210 12000    900   5300 12000 900   7100 14000 7.0 370 57
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-loops_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 20     610 180    870    1700 5400   100   1100 860 900    710 12000   900     310 11000    900     310 12000    900     160 12000    900     350 8700    5.6 290 45 7.6 490 68 8.1 380 61
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-nestedLoop_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     2500 5800    870    1500 4800   900   6200 10000 900    1200 8000   900     870 9800    .23  27 2.6  900     640 12000    900     1900 11000    15   640 130 120   2300 1700 46   1400 450
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-random1d_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     990 10000    870    610 8700   900   540 12000 890    130 11000   900     130 12000    900     130 10000    900     370 10000    900     4300 11000    900   4700 14000 900   6600 15000 10   490 76
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-random2d_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .79  40 9.2  1.4  34 15   59   480 780 7.3  76 89   .18  26 1.7  .25  26 3.0  900     1800 10000    900     3200 8000    160   4700 1900 900   6400 11000 51   1700 470
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-speedpldi2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .14  23 .72 870    1400 7400   2.8 270 24 1.5  75 17   900     240 10000    .077 26 .86 900     250 9900    900     200 12000    5.9 300 45 7.5 470 69 7.0 340 53
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-speedpldi3_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  23 .69 870    1200 8500   2.8 270 23 1.5  75 17   900     190 12000    .12  26 1.3  900     660 13000    900     1800 10000    7.0 330 52 16   700 160 8.9 490 67
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-speedpldi4_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .13  23 .78 870    1300 5500   2.9 280 27 1.4  75 14   900     250 12000    .14  26 1.0  900     120 10000    900     31 12000    5.9 300 50 8.5 530 83 6.9 320 53
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-wcet2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  23 .80 870    2700 7200   3.9 280 36 1.5  100 17   900     1100 11000    .12  26 .78 900     230 11000    900     190 12000    4.9 290 37 7.2 440 60 5.0 290 44
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-while2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .76 870    5500 5100   2.8 260 25 1.8  100 25   900     280 13000    .091 26 .71 900     310 11000    900     320 10000    6.6 320 56 7.6 480 68 6.6 320 53
termination-crafted-lit/AliasDarteFeautrierGonnord-SAS2010-wise_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .22  25 1.9  870    1100 7300   2.8 270 25 890    110 13000   900     120 12000    900     120 13000    900     210 12000    900     68 12000    8.4 380 65 14   630 120 6.5 330 56
termination-crafted-lit/Avery-FLOPS2006-Table1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     2100 12000    870    1400 5700   900   6900 11000 200    270 2800   900     310 13000    900     310 11000    900     240 11000    900     210 12000    900   5300 12000 900   6700 11000 10   520 84
termination-crafted-lit/BradleyMannaSipma-CAV2005-Fig1-modified_false-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     480 7000    870    360 7500   2.8 270 25 43    75 540   900     110 12000    900     99 10000    900     75 11000    900     66 12000    8.0 450 70 13   590 130 10   500 92
termination-crafted-lit/BradleyMannaSipma-CAV2005-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     510 6800    870    360 6900   2.8 270 24 30    75 340   900     110 11000    900     99 11000    900     72 12000    900     65 11000    7.8 420 63 19   690 190 7.6 360 60
termination-crafted-lit/BrockschmidtCookFuhs-CAV2013-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .097 25 .88 870    2400 4400   900   8000 11000 1.9  100 24   900     340 12000    .16  26 1.5  900     500 10000    900     430 10000    6.0 310 51 14   580 120 6.4 300 50
termination-crafted-lit/BrockschmidtCookFuhs-CAV2013-Fig9a_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     1200 7000    870    7000 3600   890   15000 11000 900    5300 13000   900     350 11000    900     350 11000    900     130 10000    900     170 11000    900   2500 12000 900   6100 13000 900   4900 14000
termination-crafted-lit/BrockschmidtCookFuhs-CAV2013-Introduction_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     1200 9700    870    3100 4400   900   4000 9100 130    230 1800   900     670 9900    900     670 11000    900     300 9900    900     130 11000    8.0 440 63 93   2000 1000 8.8 480 68
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-easy1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .75 4.3  62 47   2.8 270 24 1.4  75 16   .63  26 7.4  .11  26 .68 .36  11 4.5  .14  11 1.6  4.8 290 42 5.6 310 46 4.6 290 39
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-easy2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     1700 9400    870    2300 3900   900   13000 11000 160    390 2000   900     900 13000    900     900 11000    900     270 11000    900     190 12000    900   5400 13000 900   7100 14000 900   5300 11000
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-random1d_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     970 10000    870    610 10000   910   610 11000 900    130 12000   900     130 10000    900     120 11000    900     440 10000    900     4200 9700    900   8100 8900 900   6700 14000 900   3800 12000
termination-crafted-lit/ChawdharyCookGulwaniSagivYang-ESOP2008-random2d_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .75  39 10    1.4  35 18   59   460 710 13    76 150   .16  26 2.2  .28  26 3.6  900     1900 13000    900     3100 7200    160   4900 1800 900   6400 12000 50   1500 500
termination-crafted-lit/ChenCookFuhsNimkarOHearn-TACAS2014-Introduction_false-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .76 880    8400 3900   2.7 270 26 1.2  75 13   900     1200 12000    .077 26 .80 890     31 12000    .13  11 1.5  4.3 230 33 4.1 230 35 4.0 240 32
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex2.20_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .60 870    1100 7600   2.9 300 23 1.5  75 20   900     220 11000    .11  26 .75 900     100 11000    900     230 11000    4.8 280 44 5.1 280 46 4.8 290 37
termination-crafted-lit/ChenFlurMukhopadhyay-SAS2012-Ex3.01_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .67 870    1200 5600   3.0 290 26 1.2  75 16   900     190 12000    .11  26 1.1  900     160 13000    900     210 11000    4.8 290 49 5.8 320 50 5.7 300 46
termination-crafted-lit/CookSeeZuleger-TACAS2013-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .80 870    1200 7100   2.6 270 25 1.2  75 13   900     520 12000    .11  26 .74 900     360 11000    900     3900 11000    5.0 290 40 6.5 380 57 5.0 280 43
termination-crafted-lit/CookSeeZuleger-TACAS2013-Fig7a_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  23 .80 870    1600 7700   2.7 270 24 1.3  75 16   900     460 11000    .098 26 .90 900     240 11000    900     3400 13000    5.1 300 39 8.5 470 78 5.2 300 47
termination-crafted-lit/CookSeeZuleger-TACAS2013-Fig7b_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .094 23 .87 870    2000 5700   2.7 270 27 1.3  75 17   900     680 9900    .092 26 .96 900     480 11000    900     3800 8000    5.1 290 44 7.5 470 64 5.2 290 38
termination-crafted-lit/CookSeeZuleger-TACAS2013-Fig8a-modified_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .70 870    520 6500   2.8 290 27 2.0  75 25   900     140 11000    .18  26 1.7  900     27 11000    900     23 13000    5.4 300 42 6.8 460 57 5.7 300 45
termination-crafted-lit/CookSeeZuleger-TACAS2013-Fig8a_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .68 870    1100 6900   2.7 270 25 1.2  75 14   900     180 11000    .11  26 .95 900     670 9500    900     81 12000    5.5 300 51 6.0 310 47 5.7 310 44
termination-crafted-lit/CookSeeZuleger-TACAS2013-Fig8b_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .94 870    1300 7200   2.6 280 23 1.5  75 18   900     160 12000    .11  26 1.1  900     31 12000    900     51 11000    6.0 300 53 6.7 450 57 6.0 300 53
termination-crafted-lit/GopanReps-CAV2006-Fig1a_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c.c 6.7   110 77    2.7  35 32   900   7100 10000 1.4  75 16   .41  26 4.8  .46  26 6.3  .33  11 3.9  .17  11 1.6  110   3500 1400 900   6300 13000 120   4000 1500
termination-crafted-lit/HarrisLalNoriRajamani-SAS2010-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     2700 9500    870    1600 8700   900   560 11000 900    160 11000   900     230 10000    900     240 11000    900     520 11000    900     3900 13000    900   5100 12000 900   6400 12000 900   4800 13000
termination-crafted-lit/HarrisLalNoriRajamani-SAS2010-Fig3_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .79 870    1000 5700   2.6 270 23 1.3  75 14   900     900 10000    .079 26 .74 900     290 12000    900     190 12000    5.0 290 40 5.7 310 47 4.9 290 40
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     1300 9200    870    3100 4400   900   4000 9700 270    190 3600   900     990 12000    900     990 11000    900     660 13000    900     120 12000    8.0 450 69 100   2300 1300 8.6 470 76
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig4_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .71 880    4500 3700   2.6 270 22 1.4  75 17   900     490 11000    .087 26 .93 900     260 11000    900     190 13000    4.6 280 38 5.1 280 41 4.7 290 34
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig5_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .15  24 1.2  870    3400 4500   2.8 270 23 1.4  75 18   900     950 11000    900     940 11000    900     940 11000    900     250 13000    6.1 310 52 13   570 120 7.4 330 53
termination-crafted-lit/HeizmannHoenickeLeikePodelski-ATVA2013-Fig6_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .089 23 .90 870    770 4900   2.6 270 25 890    320 11000   900     190 10000    .078 26 .88 890     84 12000    900     75 12000    4.8 280 43 5.3 290 45 4.6 290 38
termination-crafted-lit/HenzingerJhalaMajumdarSutre-POPL2002-LockingExample_false-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     2400 11000    870    3000 7900   900   6800 13000 140    100 1700   900     800 9500    900     760 11000    890     180 10000    900     67 11000    900   5300 13000 900   5200 13000 900   5400 11000
termination-crafted-lit/KroeningSharyginaTsitovichWintersteiger-CAV2010-Ex_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .13  22 .69 870    1300 7400   2.5 270 20 1.5  75 19   900     190 11000    .10  26 1.1  900     480 11000    900     230 10000    4.7 270 38 4.7 260 39 4.6 290 35
termination-crafted-lit/KroeningSharyginaTsitovichWintersteiger-CAV2010-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .13  23 .74 870    1700 6300   2.7 270 24 500    110 6300   900     200 11000    .11  26 1.3  900     360 9800    900     210 11000    5.0 300 40 6.2 380 50 7.0 360 45
termination-crafted-lit/LarrazOliverasRodriguez-CarbonellRubio-FMCAD2013-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     1000 7100    870    640 8300   900   510 13000 890    130 9500   900     250 14000    900     230 12000    900     51 14000    900     45 14000    900   1200 12000 900   6000 12000 900   990 12000
termination-crafted-lit/LeeJonesBen-Amram-POPL2001-Ex4_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .67 870    7400 6500   3.0 270 24 580    15000 7300   590     15000 7100    690     15000 7100    900     500 11000    900     240 14000    9.0 510 67 9.3 520 86 11   540 99
termination-crafted-lit/LeeJonesBen-Amram-POPL2001-Ex5_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .65 490    15000 5000   900   5300 10000 450    15000 6000   510     15000 5600    890     15000 7600    900     710 9400    900     160 12000    17   700 160 900   5600 14000 8.7 450 70
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-TACAS2014-Ex1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .090 23 .81 870    980 5900   2.6 270 26 2.1  75 25   900     180 13000    .29  26 3.3  900     71 11000    900     44 11000    5.4 300 45 11   520 100 5.6 320 48
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-TACAS2014-Ex9_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  25 .82 870    1800 5700   2.7 270 24 1.3  75 14   900     560 13000    .12  26 .70 900     190 11000    900     40 12000    4.9 290 38 6.8 470 56 4.9 290 43
termination-crafted-lit/LeikeHeizmann-WST2014-Ex9_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .78 2.5  37 27   2.6 260 23 1.4  75 15   .20  26 2.5  .11  26 .59 1.8   12 24    .15  11 1.7  4.8 280 43 4.9 270 42 4.5 280 37
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-LICS2004-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 18     610 170    870    1700 4300   110   1000 790 1.8  100 20   900     320 11000    900     310 13000    900     170 10000    900     190 11000    5.5 290 50 7.0 470 63 6.2 300 52
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-TACAS2011-Fig1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .69 870    4400 3300   2.5 270 21 1.4  75 15   900     740 9600    .075 26 .86 900     280 11000    900     240 12000    4.5 280 41 4.6 260 39 4.8 280 35
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-TACAS2011-Fig2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .78 870    2400 3400   2.6 270 25 1.7  100 18   900     350 12000    .12  26 1.2  890     480 9800    900     680 12000    6.0 300 53 7.0 480 64 6.4 300 49
termination-crafted-lit/PodelskiRybalchenko-TACAS2011-Fig4_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .94 870    1300 5700   2.7 270 23 1.2  75 14   900     470 10000    .083 26 .95 900     370 12000    900     3900 8100    4.9 290 40 6.0 340 52 4.9 290 35
termination-crafted-lit/Urban-WST2013-Fig1_false-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .76 870    2800 5700   2.6 260 23 1.4  75 17   900     300 9900    .096 26 .98 900     12 12000    .16  12 2.0  4.5 290 37 4.4 260 39 4.6 280 36
termination-crafted-lit/Urban-WST2013-Fig2-modified1000_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  23 .78 870    13000 12000   900   4900 12000 1.4  100 16   900     3600 12000    .085 26 .75 890     330 9100    900     190 11000    5.4 300 46 6.6 420 51 5.9 300 48
termination-crafted-lit/Urban-WST2013-Fig2_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .13  23 .75 870    780 4400   4.1 290 39 1.4  100 20   900     670 10000    .11  26 .65 900     760 13000    900     210 12000    5.5 300 50 6.9 430 57 5.9 300 46
termination-crafted-lit/UrbanMine-ESOP2014-Fig3_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  23 .82 870    2600 7900   2.8 270 26 1.3  75 17   900     420 12000    .14  26 1.0  900     370 11000    900     3700 11000    5.8 300 46 7.8 470 68 6.9 310 58
termination-crafted-lit/Velroyen_false-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .88 870    2900 5600   2.6 270 24 1.3  75 14   900     400 9900    .10  26 1.0  .30  11 3.4  900     15000 12000    4.8 280 39 4.8 260 37 4.8 290 37
termination-crafted-lit/aviad_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 3.6   94 42    8.1  180 93   900   8100 11000 22    75 260   5.7   32 72    6.1   33 77    900     290 10000    900     330 8500    350   5700 4500 900   5800 12000 7.7 380 63
termination-crafted-lit/cstrcmp_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .16  24 1.6  870    8400 3400   3.4 310 31 1.4  75 20   900     5700 10000    .19  27 1.7  .074 11 .37 .22  13 2.3  5.1 280 41 5.4 300 50 5.1 290 47
termination-crafted-lit/cstrcspn_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .16  24 1.3  870    1200 3900   3.4 310 29 900    590 11000   900     1400 9900    .14  27 1.9  .073 11 .34 .22  13 2.6  5.2 280 45 5.7 310 54 5.4 290 42
termination-crafted-lit/cstrlen_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .17  23 1.4  870    7500 3700   2.8 280 25 1.4  75 14   900     2900 9000    .15  27 1.3  .074 11 .37 .18  12 2.1  4.9 290 40 5.5 300 40 5.3 280 45
termination-crafted-lit/cstrpbrk_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .17  24 1.6  870    1200 3400   3.3 310 32 900    530 11000   900     1900 11000    .16  27 1.5  .061 11 .50 .22  13 2.0  5.2 280 42 5.5 310 47 5.1 290 37
termination-crafted-lit/cstrspn_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .19  24 1.2  870    1200 4400   3.3 310 31 900    560 11000   900     1800 8300    .16  27 1.7  .071 11 .40 .22  13 2.4  5.2 290 41 5.6 300 45 5.2 290 43
termination-crafted-lit/genady_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .98  30 11    9.4  160 110   900   4500 11000 54    75 780   900     12000 8100    900     11000 10000    .40  11 4.7  .19  12 2.5  8.1 420 71 36   1000 410 6.5 310 49
termination-crafted-lit/strchr_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .20  24 1.4  730    8500 3800   2.8 290 23 .54 75 5.6 900     1800 11000    .12  27 1.4  .067 11 .45 .19  12 2.2  5.1 290 40 5.7 320 48 5.4 290 41
termination-numeric/Addition01_false-no-overflow.c .099 22 .71 .27 33 2.4 3.1 310 28 .54 49 6.3 .17  28 1.6  .20  28 1.5  .45  12 5.9  .16  12 2.0  4.3 250 37 4.4 260 37 4.3 250 35
termination-numeric/Avg_true_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .69 .27 35 2.2 2.6 270 24 .59 49 6.6 .18  28 1.8  .17  28 1.8  .65  12 7.4  .19  12 1.7  4.2 250 35 4.4 260 38 4.3 250 32
termination-numeric/Binomial_true-termination_false-no-overflow.c .10  22 .83 23    250 280   900   2000 8300 27    140 330   8.0   80 110    5.5   64 71    1.1   12 13    .24  12 3.1  900   1100 6600 900   2300 8700 900   4800 12000
termination-numeric/Et1_true_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .66 .27 33 1.8 2.6 270 21 .45 49 5.3 .20  28 2.0  .24  28 2.0  1.3   13 16    .18  12 1.7  4.1 240 38 4.2 250 35 4.3 250 33
termination-numeric/Et2_true_false-no-overflow.c .099 22 .67 .28 33 2.3 2.7 260 27 .58 49 8.0 .22  28 2.2  .27  28 2.7  1.1   13 15    .19  12 1.8  4.3 240 35 4.2 250 36 4.4 250 36
termination-numeric/Et3_true_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .60 .25 33 2.1 2.6 270 21 .54 49 7.3 .19  28 1.9  .22  28 2.1  1.2   13 17    .16  12 1.9  4.2 250 37 4.4 250 36 4.2 250 33
termination-numeric/Et4_true_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .61 .27 34 2.5 2.7 270 23 .49 49 5.3 .39  28 3.6  .44  28 3.5  .98  13 12    .19  12 1.7  4.5 250 38 4.4 250 36 4.4 250 41
termination-numeric/MultCommutative_false-no-overflow.c .11  22 .77 .30 34 2.5 900   1600 11000 480    15000 5900   .30  28 2.8  .43  29 4.7  .65  12 6.9  .27  12 2.8  8.1 450 74 11   600 120 9.2 450 80
termination-numeric/TerminatorRec02_true-termination_false-no-overflow.c .10  22 .69 2.0  78 25   900   1600 7500 1.7  140 21   16     51 180    23     57 310    41     39 580    12     39 160    900   740 6400 900   2100 10000 60   690 750
termination-numeric/Ackermann01_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .67 870    330 2600   900   6500 10000 460    15000 6400   460     15000 4900    620     15000 6600    890     17 13000    900     2000 11000    900   13000 9900 900   1700 11000 900   13000 5700
termination-numeric/EvenOdd01_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .097 22 .65 870    2800 6600   900   4300 11000 1.6  49 21   900     1100 11000    900     1100 12000    900     770 10000    900     300 14000    10   540 86 900   5000 12000 7.3 370 64
termination-numeric/Fibonacci01_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .80 870    260 3000   5.3 310 57 380    15000 4700   900     8800 6500    900     11000 11000    900     1400 11000    900     250 13000    900   4700 11000 900   1500 10000 58   1600 420
termination-numeric/LeUserDefRec_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .098 22 .74 730    15000 5200   3.0 280 24 1.3  49 14   900     900 10000    900     900 9800    890     380 12000    900     230 12000    5.6 290 43 7.6 490 65 5.1 290 45
termination-numeric/LogRecursive_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .093 22 .68 5.0  91 55   900   1900 9300 2.0  77 24   84     160 1000    110     170 1200    35     170 440    20     170 290    900   490 11000 900   5300 12000 900   1400 11000
termination-numeric/Parts_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .72 870    840 5700   900   2900 10000 900    430 8100   900     2900 13000    900     3700 13000    900     350 12000    900     3200 11000    900   5300 13000 900   1900 11000 900   13000 6200
termination-numeric/TwoWay_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .61 870    2500 4600   900   740 11000 5.8  150 52   900     190 9600    900     190 10000    900     790 8500    900     350 9700    12   530 120 900   2500 9500 33   700 390
termination-numeric/gcd01_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .098 22 .85 880    5000 4800   3.5 310 33 430    15000 5400   900     890 8600    900     1600 8300    900     89 11000    900     49 12000    5.7 300 50 8.4 470 73 5.3 310 42
termination-numeric/java_LogBuiltIn_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .55  39 6.7  2.7  38 29   15   460 160 1.4  75 17   .22  26 2.2  .22  26 2.8  1.9   12 26    .31  12 4.1  44   1200 460 170   4700 2200 70   1300 690
termination-numeric/recHanoi02_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .099 22 .76 2.6  36 25   900   4400 9800 1.8  49 20   1.9   28 24    2.0   27 27    2.1   13 27    .65  16 7.7  59   1500 640 900   4600 13000 900   2500 11000
termination-numeric/rec_counter1_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .71 870    5800 4000   900   4500 12000 2.5  97 30   900     1100 10000    900     1100 9900    900     2100 9600    900     500 12000    900   5600 14000 900   5700 15000 900   5500 14000
termination-numeric/rec_counter3_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .70 870    5800 4600   900   5700 11000 2.4  99 28   900     1200 12000    900     1100 9700    900     1900 9300    900     480 13000    900   5600 13000 900   5800 12000 900   5500 11000
termination-numeric/twisted_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c 900     24 9800    170    13000 1900   900   7800 11000 900    6600 13000   900     1200 12000    900     1000 9000    900     670 11000    900     1800 9700    900   1300 11000 900   5600 12000 900   1300 13000
recursive/Addition02WithOverflowBug_false-no-overflow.c .079 22 .75 .28 35 2.1 2.8 280 25 .56 49 7.6 .22  28 1.8  .16  28 3.3  .43  12 5.7  .19  12 2.1  6.0 330 42 4.4 250 40 4.1 230 36
recursive/Addition03_false-no-overflow.c .090 22 .98 .27 33 2.2 3.1 300 29 .56 49 7.1 .17  28 1.7  .18  28 1.8  .42  12 5.4  .17  12 1.9  4.4 240 35 4.5 260 39 4.1 240 39
recursive/EvenOdd03WithOverflowBug_false-no-overflow.c .11  23 .60 .25 33 2.5 2.6 270 22 64    73 750   .12  28 1.4  .12  28 1.4  .37  12 4.7  .20  12 1.8  4.8 290 44 4.6 270 42 4.8 290 39
recursive/Ackermann01_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .66 870    330 2900   900   3600 12000 450    15000 5400   440     15000 5400    620     15000 7700    890     17 12000    900     2100 12000    900   12000 10000 900   1700 11000 910   13000 5800
recursive/Ackermann02_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .11  22 .64 870    360 3500   900   4300 9600 460    15000 5300   450     15000 5100    630     15000 7700    890     19 14000    900     2500 11000    900   13000 10000 900   1800 13000 910   13000 6500
recursive/Ackermann03_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .60 870    350 3400   900   4500 12000 460    15000 5500   460     15000 5000    640     15000 7100    890     18 12000    900     2100 11000    910   13000 9400 900   1700 10000 910   13000 6600
recursive/Ackermann04_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .62 870    340 3000   900   5700 10000 460    15000 5900   450     15000 4700    610     15000 8800    890     18 12000    900     2100 13000    910   13000 8200 900   1700 11000 910   13000 5400
recursive/Addition01_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .090 22 .81 860    15000 8000   900   5700 10000 400    15000 5400   810     15000 9200    580     15000 5800    890     650 9400    900     29 11000    900   5200 13000 900   6000 15000 900   4400 12000
recursive/Addition02_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .097 22 .81 880    15000 9100   900   5700 9100 400    15000 5100   840     15000 8100    580     15000 7200    900     640 10000    900     72 14000    900   5200 12000 900   6000 12000 900   5100 12000
recursive/Addition03_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .11  22 .71 880    6800 4600   2.8 270 24 400    15000 5000   830     15000 9000    570     15000 6000    .076 11 .38 900     63 12000    900   5200 11000 900   5800 14000 900   2600 12000
recursive/BallRajamani-SPIN2000-Fig1_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .11  22 .65 .43 33 3.9 2.8 270 26 1.2  49 14   .081 26 .85 .073 26 .77 .38  11 5.5  .15  11 1.4  4.2 240 34 4.2 250 31 4.4 250 35
recursive/EvenOdd01_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .099 22 .73 870    2800 6500   900   4100 10000 64    74 900   900     1100 10000    900     1100 10000    890     850 12000    900     320 12000    10   520 90 900   4800 13000 7.3 380 60
recursive/EvenOdd03_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .12  22 .61 870    2800 7400   900   4400 9800 64    75 710   900     1100 13000    900     1100 10000    890     830 11000    900     300 11000    11   510 98 900   5200 9700 7.7 380 55
recursive/Fibonacci01_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.c .082 22 .71 870    260 3700   4.4 290 39 860    15000 11000   900     8800 7500    900     4400 8600    890     13 13000    900     220 9700    900   5000 11000 900   1300 11000 900   5000 12000
recursive/Fibonacci02_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .096 22 .87 1.3  33 13   670   810 6100 1.4  49 16   .15  26 1.4  .16  26 1.4  .29  11 3.2  .18  11 1.7  36   3800 410 900   1400 11000 900   13000 7200
recursive/Fibonacci03_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .085 22 .81 870    260 3000   5.9 310 63 380    15000 5100   900     8800 7000    900     11000 11000    890     13 13000    900     220 11000    900   5400 11000 900   1300 12000 63   1500 490
recursive/Fibonacci04_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .12  22 .67 870    250 2500   4.2 300 40 380    15000 4700   900     8800 6700    900     11000 9300    900     1400 11000    900     280 12000    900   5000 13000 900   1500 11000 59   1500 450
recursive/Fibonacci05_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .093 22 .73 870    260 2900   4.2 290 42 380    15000 5100   900     8800 7100    900     11000 8600    900     1300 12000    900     270 11000    900   4800 11000 900   1600 11000 58   1600 440
recursive/McCarthy91_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .083 22 .86 870    2000 3500   3.4 280 26 510    15000 6900   900     6400 7800    900     9100 10000    900     140 11000    900     74 11000    6.8 310 53 7.0 440 56 6.6 310 53
recursive/McCarthy91_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .094 22 .73 870    2000 3700   3.3 280 29 510    15000 6100   900     6300 7100    900     9000 8700    900     160 10000    900     74 12000    6.5 310 54 7.1 430 60 6.8 320 61
recursive/MultCommutative_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .082 22 .93 870    450 2100   900   1500 10000 480    15000 6400   700     15000 6700    380     15000 3900    890     80 12000    900     330 14000    900   3100 12000 900   2000 13000 240   4800 2700
recursive/Primes_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_false-termination.c .12  23 .71 870    310 4100   900   1500 12000 530    15000 6700   220     15000 2400    450     15000 6100    900     53 13000    900     44 11000    900   5000 14000 900   1500 12000 900   6800 12000
recursive/gcd01_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .098 22 .76 870    5000 4200   3.4 310 29 420    15000 4600   900     890 8600    900     1600 9200    900     88 13000    900     49 14000    5.7 300 47 8.3 480 70 5.7 300 49
recursive/gcd02_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .10  22 .76 880    7200 5900   3.5 290 33 420    15000 5400   900     1200 9200    900     2300 8300    890     36 12000    900     29 12000    11   530 100 14   640 130 32   820 270
recursive/recHanoi01_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .082 22 .81 870    1400 2900   900   6800 9900 410    15000 4700   900     13000 10000    900     5300 6400    890     13 12000    900     1200 12000    900   4700 14000 900   2900 11000 910   13000 8900
recursive/recHanoi02_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .094 22 .79 2.6  36 27   900   5000 12000 1.9  49 21   1.9   28 25    2.0   27 29    2.1   12 27    .64  14 8.4  60   1500 600 900   4700 13000 900   2700 11000
recursive/recHanoi03_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.c .10  22 .65 2.6  36 28   900   4400 9800 1.8  49 20   1.9   27 24    2.0   28 27    2.1   13 27    .71  14 10    57   1700 520 900   4600 14000 900   2500 11000
recursive-simple/id_b3_o2_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .55 .24 33 2.0 2.8 270 24 .54 49 8.3 .16  28 .91 .13  28 1.6  .37  12 4.8  .16  12 2.4  4.6 290 37 4.5 270 45 4.5 280 40
recursive-simple/id_b3_o5_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .71 .27 33 2.1 2.8 280 23 .56 49 7.3 .13  28 1.3  .17  28 1.2  .37  12 4.0  .18  12 1.9  4.8 280 35 4.4 260 34 4.7 280 37
recursive-simple/id_b5_o10_false-no-overflow.c .096 22 .74 .26 33 2.2 3.0 300 25 .57 49 6.4 .15  28 1.1  .13  28 1.4  .38  12 4.0  .17  12 2.2  4.7 280 39 4.7 260 36 4.7 280 39
recursive-simple/sum_non_eq_false-no-overflow.c .12  22 .69 .26 33 2.1 2.9 270 20 .56 49 6.4 .21  28 1.7  .21  28 1.7  .41  12 4.4  .19  12 2.0  4.8 280 40 4.7 260 37 4.7 290 38
recursive-simple/sum_non_false-no-overflow.c .10  22 .66 .24 33 2.2 2.7 270 26 .57 49 8.8 .18  28 1.9  .22  28 1.8  .47  12 6.2  .17  12 1.9  5.2 300 46 5.8 330 49 5.4 310 40
recursive-simple/id2_b2_o3_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .67 870    5200 5200   3.0 270 28 1.5  49 16   900     1200 9500    900     1200 11000    900     690 10000    .14  11 1.4  4.2 250 38 4.1 250 32 4.2 250 32
recursive-simple/id2_b3_o2_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .089 22 .73 870    5200 5900   3.0 290 30 1.5  49 17   900     1200 9200    900     1200 12000    900     660 12000    .15  11 1.4  4.2 250 34 4.4 250 39 4.1 240 35
recursive-simple/id2_b3_o5_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .73 870    5200 5700   2.9 270 27 1.5  49 17   900     1200 9500    900     1200 10000    900     700 11000    .15  11 1.4  4.0 240 33 4.1 250 32 4.1 250 40
recursive-simple/id2_b5_o10_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .75 870    5200 4800   2.8 270 23 1.5  49 20   900     1200 9500    900     1200 10000    890     660 8300    .15  11 1.4  4.1 250 39 4.1 240 36 4.2 250 34
recursive-simple/id_b2_o3_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .098 22 .65 870    9200 4300   2.8 270 27 1.4  49 17   900     1200 9900    900     1200 9900    890     1200 8500    .13  11 1.3  4.0 230 35 4.2 240 33 4.1 250 36
recursive-simple/id_b3_o2_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .64 880    5200 7500   3.7 290 32 .53 49 5.9 900     460 11000    900     470 11000    .38  12 4.2  900     2300 12000    6.2 310 53 6.3 350 47 7.8 370 62
recursive-simple/id_b3_o5_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .73 870    5200 7600   3.7 290 31 .56 49 7.0 900     460 11000    900     470 11000    .36  12 5.1  900     2300 9300    6.0 310 52 6.5 350 52 8.1 370 63
recursive-simple/id_b5_o10_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .12  22 .66 880    6100 5000   4.5 300 40 .56 49 6.3 900     470 12000    900     470 11000    .37  12 5.6  900     2500 9100    5.9 300 55 6.7 360 51 8.1 380 68
recursive-simple/id_o1000_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .089 22 .64 640    15000 3900   2.8 260 24 1.2  49 16   900     1100 9900    900     1100 11000    890     1000 8900    .15  11 1.3  4.1 250 35 4.2 240 37 4.0 250 36
recursive-simple/id_o100_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .11  22 .75 660    15000 3800   2.9 290 25 1.2  49 15   900     1100 8700    900     1100 9600    890     1100 9100    .15  11 1.5  4.3 240 35 4.2 240 35 4.2 240 32
recursive-simple/id_o10_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .082 22 .76 560    15000 5600   2.7 260 25 1.2  49 13   900     1100 10000    900     1100 11000    890     1100 9600    .13  11 1.2  4.1 240 38 4.0 240 38 3.9 250 33
recursive-simple/id_o200_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .098 22 .64 670    15000 3700   3.0 300 25 1.2  49 13   900     1100 12000    900     1100 12000    890     1000 8100    .15  11 1.4  4.1 240 37 3.9 240 34 4.1 240 37
recursive-simple/id_o20_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .097 22 .63 650    15000 3600   3.0 290 24 1.2  49 14   900     1100 11000    900     1100 11000    900     1100 8800    .13  11 1.5  4.1 240 34 4.2 240 36 4.1 250 34
recursive-simple/id_o3_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .095 22 .86 660    15000 3400   2.8 270 25 1.2  49 13   900     1100 10000    900     1100 9700    900     1000 9600    .15  11 1.5  4.2 250 35 3.9 230 32 4.2 250 37
recursive-simple/sum_non_eq_false-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .095 22 .70 780    15000 6300   2.8 270 27 1.2  49 14   900     1000 9300    900     1000 10000    900     740 9200    .16  11 1.3  3.8 240 34 4.0 240 34 4.3 250 31
recursive-simple/sum_non_eq_true-unreach-call_true-termination_true-no-overflow.c .10  22 .78 870    15000 4000   2.8 270 23 1.2  49 14   900     1000 9100    900     1000 12000    890     730 8800    .13  11 1.4  3.9 240 32 4.0 250 35 4.2 250 38
bitvector/byte_add_1_false-no-overflow.i .34  31 4.2  .66 33 6.1 5.9 320 55 1.8  100 23   1.1   29 11    1.1   29 11    4.1   13 49    .25  12 2.7  25   650 250 900   1200 11000 110   4000 1100
bitvector/byte_add_2_false-no-overflow.i .36  31 3.5  .66 34 6.6 6.4 330 55 1.8  100 21   .98  29 7.9  1.1   29 9.6  4.1   13 49    .25  12 2.2  38   800 370 900   1300 12000 230   4600 2600
bitvector/byte_add_false-no-overflow.i .36  31 4.0  .68 33 5.9 6.8 350 57 2.1  110 23   1.3   29 12    1.4   29 9.9  39     17 440    .28  13 3.4  69   810 790 900   1200 12000 160   2700 1800
bitvector/jain_1_false-no-overflow.i .093 22 .79 .24 33 1.8 2.8 280 29 .56 75 6.5 .080 28 1.0  .10  28 .83 .44  12 5.1  .19  12 1.7  4.2 250 37 4.4 250 35 4.2 240 38
bitvector/jain_2_false-no-overflow.i .14  23 .86 .23 33 2.5 2.9 290 24 .63 75 8.3 .11  28 .88 .13  28 .87 .70  12 9.5  .20  12 2.0  4.1 240 34 4.1 250 32 4.2 240 39
bitvector/jain_4_false-no-overflow.i .13  24 .94 .24 34 2.5 2.9 280 29 29    80 330   .088 28 .91 .11  28 1.2  .59  12 8.2  .18  12 2.2  4.2 240 33 4.3 250 37 4.4 250 40
bitvector/jain_5_false-no-overflow.i 900     1100 8900    370    15000 5400   900   3900 8100 900    2300 11000   900     12000 8900    900     12000 9600    2.3   11 29    .50  40 8.0  900   5200 12000 900   6000 13000 900   1500 13000
bitvector/jain_6_false-no-overflow.i .13  26 .98 .26 34 2.4 2.9 290 26 24    80 320   .12  28 .81 .14  28 1.2  .72  12 8.0  .19  12 1.8  4.3 250 37 6.6 350 51 4.4 250 38
bitvector/jain_7_false-no-overflow.i .13  24 .93 .27 33 2.2 2.8 280 24 93    97 1300   .091 28 1.1  .13  28 1.1  .70  12 8.5  .19  12 1.9  4.2 250 35 4.3 250 34 4.4 250 37
bitvector/modulus_false-no-overflow.i .15  26 1.1  .24 33 2.0 2.6 270 21 .50 100 5.3 .16  28 2.0  .18  28 1.6  .35  12 4.5  .18  11 2.4  4.2 240 36 4.3 250 36 4.4 250 30
bitvector/byte_add_1_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.i .12  24 .92 .86 34 8.4 3.8 310 36 1.9  100 21   .13  27 1.7  .098 27 1.0  4.1   13 48    .33  12 4.3  5.0 280 41 7.4 370 61 5.1 280 43
bitvector/byte_add_2_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.i .12  24 1.0  .86 33 7.8 3.4 280 31 1.8  100 23   .14  27 1.6  .12  27 1.0  4.1   13 55    .36  12 4.1  5.5 290 45 7.3 370 60 5.5 280 40
bitvector/byte_add_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.i .10  24 1.0  .88 33 8.8 3.5 280 32 2.0  110 25   .21  27 2.3  .10  27 1.1  38     18 460    .84  13 10    5.1 290 41 7.4 370 59 5.0 280 37
bitvector/gcd_1_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .12  25 1.1  .53 35 5.4 2.8 280 25 500    99 6600   .56  29 7.4  .35  27 4.7  .66  12 8.4  .31  12 4.3  5.5 310 44 5.2 300 43 5.5 330 45
bitvector/gcd_2_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .11  24 .89 1.6  42 19   2.8 270 24 20    75 270   9.9   43 110    .29  26 3.0  28     18 380    21     16 260    5.5 290 46 5.7 330 45 5.4 280 39
bitvector/gcd_3_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .096 23 1.2  1.6  42 17   2.7 270 25 21    75 250   9.9   43 120    .26  27 3.2  30     17 380    25     16 340    5.3 290 44 5.9 330 49 5.2 280 38
bitvector/gcd_4_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_true-termination.i .56  33 6.1  .81 33 7.0 2.7 270 24 500    110 7100   .12  26 .72 .15  26 1.7  .078 11 .36 .17  11 1.7  11   540 92 33   1100 360 19   640 170
bitvector/interleave_bits_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .12  24 .95 1.6  33 16   2.5 270 23 1.4  76 16   .11  26 .96 .078 26 .74 .37  11 3.7  .15  11 1.6  4.3 250 34 4.2 250 39 4.2 250 35
bitvector/jain_1_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_false-termination.i .086 22 .77 870    910 4200   2.6 280 23 1.2  75 16   900     1200 11000    .079 26 .77 900     92 9600    .15  11 1.5  4.2 250 35 3.9 230 32 4.2 250 35
bitvector/jain_2_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_false-termination.i .096 22 .64 870    1300 4700   2.6 270 26 1.2  75 13   900     790 10000    .12  26 .76 900     120 7600    .14  11 1.5  6.6 340 48 4.2 240 38 4.1 250 31
bitvector/jain_4_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_false-termination.i .096 22 .73 870    1600 5300   2.6 270 24 1.2  75 15   900     730 9800    .094 26 .96 890     120 12000    .14  11 1.5  4.0 240 33 3.9 240 31 3.9 230 32
bitvector/jain_5_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .099 22 .74 380    15000 4500   2.5 270 23 1.2  75 13   900     11000 10000    .089 26 .74 890     11 11000    .13  11 1.3  4.2 250 40 4.4 250 33 4.2 250 34
bitvector/jain_6_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_false-termination.i .12  23 .72 870    1600 4300   2.6 270 26 1.2  75 13   900     730 8900    .11  26 .88 .48  12 5.7  .15  11 1.5  4.1 240 34 4.1 240 33 4.1 240 36
bitvector/jain_7_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow_false-termination.i .10  23 .80 870    1600 3700   2.7 270 24 1.2  75 13   900     1000 12000    .080 26 .80 .49  12 6.5  .15  11 1.6  4.0 240 32 4.1 250 36 4.0 240 33
bitvector/modulus_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .13  28 .97 120    1000 660   2.7 270 25 900    630 6900   74     290 910    .14  26 1.2  790     64 12000    660     62 8800    4.3 240 36 4.3 250 35 4.3 250 34
bitvector/num_conversion_1_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .10  22 .80 1.2  33 12   2.8 270 25 1.4  75 15   .092 26 .98 .11  26 .90 .33  11 3.9  .17  11 1.8  4.2 250 35 4.3 250 38 4.3 250 36
bitvector/num_conversion_2_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .11  22 .80 1.2  33 12   3.0 270 24 1.4  75 16   .11  26 1.0  .087 26 .75 .30  11 3.5  .99  13 9.3  4.5 250 32 4.1 250 35 4.0 240 33
bitvector/parity_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .10  22 .89 2.5  34 25   2.8 260 24 1.4  76 19   .82  26 9.4  .10  26 .84 9.4   13 120    .13  11 1.5  4.3 250 35 4.1 240 35 4.2 250 34
bitvector/sum02_false-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .12  25 .71 870    6800 5100   2.8 270 24 1.2  75 13   900     1400 9700    .093 26 .77 900     670 11000    .13  11 1.4  4.1 240 33 4.3 240 36 4.3 240 35
bitvector/sum02_true-unreach-call_true-no-overflow.i .11  24 1.0  870    6400 3800   2.7 270 24 1.2  75 17   900     1400 11000    .074 26 .89 .065 11 .53 .15  11 1.5  4.1 240 34 4.3 240 34 4.2 250 34
../sv-benchmarks/c/ status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J) status cpu (s) mem (MB) energy (J)
total 358 26000   49000 280000 358 130000   650000 770000 358 59000 400000 700000 358 40000 540000 490000 358 130000 500000 1500000 358 77000 440000 890000 358 130000   210000 1600000 358 110000 130000 1400000 358 42000 360000 550000 358 65000 400000 860000 358 38000 340000 460000
    correct results 228 91   7100 860 192 100   6800 1100 285 2000 82000 18000 13 150 850 2000 197 92 5600 1000 259 89 7200 990 157 220   1900 2700 222 98 2700 1200 304 2500 110000 24000 285 2400 100000 25000 301 2200 99000 20000
        correct true 88 73   3800 720 29 59   1400 660 121 1300 36000 12000 0 28 32 780 370 90 17 2400 180 26 120   320 1600 53 55 590 700 141 1700 68000 18000 122 1300 54000 13000 138 1200 54000 11000
        correct false 140 19   3300 140 163 46   5500 410 164 660 46000 5600 13 150 850 2000 169 60 4800 630 169 72 4800 800 131 94   1600 1200 169 43 2100 500 163 760 44000 6500 163 1100 48000 11000 163 980 45000 8700
    correct-unconfimed results 4 6.7 350 65 11 140   1400 840 10 38 2900 360 149 630 15000 8500 7 160 590 2000 8 110 350 1300 21 880   490 13000 7 680 300 9100 3 180 4700 1800 0 9 520 13000 4800
        correct-unconfirmed true 4 6.7 350 65 8 130   1300 820 10 38 2900 360 0 7 160 590 2000 8 110 350 1300 6 830   280 13000 7 680 300 9100 3 180 4700 1800 0 9 520 13000 4800
        correct-unconfirmed false 0 3 2.0 100 19 0 149 630 15000 8500 0 0 15 49   210 670 0 0 0 0
    incorrect results 0 0 0 5 490 650 5400 0 0 10 50   130 580 0 0 0 1 60 690 750
        incorrect true 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 48   67 560 0 0 0 1 60 690 750
        incorrect false 0 0 0 5 490 650 5400 0 0 5 2.1 59 27 0 0 0 0
Run set 2ls.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] cbmc.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] cpa-seq.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] depthk.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] esbmc-incr.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] esbmc-kind.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] map2check.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] symbiotic.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] uautomizer.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] ukojak.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other] utaipan.[sv-comp18.NoOverflows-BitVectors; sv-comp18.NoOverflows-Other]